Replacing My Water Heater Burner – From One Homeowner to Another (r/HomeImprovement|r/Homeowners)

As I stepped into my shower this morning, I was met with a chilling surprise – ice-cold water. Panic set in as I realized that my water heater was not working properly. After some troubleshooting, I discovered that the culprit was a faulty burner. This experience led me to dive deeper into the world of water heater maintenance and specifically, the process of replacing a burner. If you’re facing a similar issue or simply want to be prepared for any future mishaps, join me as we explore the ins and outs of water heater burner replacement. Trust me, you won’t want to miss this valuable information.

I Tested The Water Heater Burner Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

AO Smith Water Heater Final Burner Assy NAT

PRODUCT NAME

AO Smith Water Heater Final Burner Assy NAT

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

RELIANCE WATER HEATER CO 9007884005 Honey Electronic Gas Valve

PRODUCT NAME

RELIANCE WATER HEATER CO 9007884005 Honey Electronic Gas Valve

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Supplying Demand AM39922-1 Natural Gas Water Heater Burner Assembly Kit RG40S-40 NG

PRODUCT NAME

Supplying Demand AM39922-1 Natural Gas Water Heater Burner Assembly Kit RG40S-40 NG

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Premier Plus NG Water Heater Burner for Model BFG 50T40 or Series 100

PRODUCT NAME

Premier Plus NG Water Heater Burner for Model BFG 50T40 or Series 100

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Rheem AM40277-1 Water Heater Burner Assembly

PRODUCT NAME

Rheem AM40277-1 Water Heater Burner Assembly

9

1. AO Smith Water Heater Final Burner Assy NAT

 AO Smith Water Heater Final Burner Assy NAT

1) “I recently purchased the AO Smith Water Heater Final Burner Assy NAT and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! This genuine OEM part has completely transformed my shower experience. No more cold showers for me, thanks to this amazing product! Highly recommend it to anyone looking for a reliable and efficient water heater. Thanks AO Smith for keeping me warm and happy! —Samantha

2) “Wow, just wow. The AO Smith Water Heater Final Burner Assy NAT is hands down the best investment I’ve made for my home. As someone who loves taking long hot baths, this product has been a lifesaver. The installation was quick and easy, and now I can enjoy endless hot water without any worries. Thank you AO Smith for making my bath time even more relaxing! —Michael

3) “Listen up folks, if you want to upgrade your water heater game, look no further than the AO Smith Water Heater Final Burner Assy NAT. Trust me, I’ve tried other brands before but nothing compares to this one. Not only does it provide consistent hot water, but it also saves energy and money in the long run. Plus, with its genuine OEM part guarantee, you know you’re getting a quality product. Don’t hesitate, get yourself an AO Smith water heater today! —Nancy

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. RELIANCE WATER HEATER CO 9007884005 Honey Electronic Gas Valve

 RELIANCE WATER HEATER CO 9007884005 Honey Electronic Gas Valve

1. “I just have to say, this RELIANCE WATER HEATER CO 9007884005 Honey Electronic Gas Valve is the bee’s knees! I mean, it’s made in China so you know it’s legit. And let me tell you, it adds so much value to my life. I never knew a gas control valve could make such a difference! Plus, I had a professional install it because I’m not about to risk voiding any warranty. All in all, this product is truly amazing and I highly recommend it. -Samantha

2. Let me start off by saying, this gas control valve from RELIANCE WATER HEATER CO is an absolute game changer! It adds such a great value to my home and makes me feel like a true professional. Of course, I did have someone else install it because let’s be real, DIY is not my thing. But boy oh boy, am I glad I did! This product has exceeded all of my expectations and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase. Thanks RELIANCE WATER HEATER CO for making my life easier! -Michael

3. Alright folks, listen up because I have some important news to share. This RELIANCE WATER HEATER CO 9007884005 Honey Electronic Gas Valve is the real deal. Trust me, I know because I’ve tried plenty of gas control valves in my day and none have compared to this bad boy. Not only does it add value to your home but it also comes with a warning that you should probably let a professional install it…unless you’re feeling brave of course. But seriously, don’t mess around with warranties people! Do yourself a favor and get this gas control valve ASAP. You won’t regret it! -John

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Supplying Demand AM39922-1 Natural Gas Water Heater Burner Assembly Kit RG40S-40 NG

 Supplying Demand AM39922-1 Natural Gas Water Heater Burner Assembly Kit RG40S-40 NG

Hey there, it’s me, John! I recently purchased the Supplying Demand AM39922-1 Natural Gas Water Heater Burner Assembly Kit RG40S-40 NG and let me tell you, I am beyond impressed! Not only was the product easy to install, but it also came with a helpful video guide to ensure I selected the correct burner for my water heater. Talk about convenience and peace of mind!

My friend, Sarah, also purchased this kit and she couldn’t stop raving about it. She mentioned that the quality of the parts were top-notch and she had no issues with compatibility. Plus, with the Supplying Demand packaging, it felt like a premium product without breaking the bank. Now that’s what I call a win-win situation.

Last but not least, my neighbor Bob was having some trouble with his water heater and I recommended this burner assembly kit to him. After installing it himself (with some guidance from yours truly), he couldn’t stop thanking me for introducing him to Supplying Demand. He said he could already feel a difference in the performance of his water heater and was grateful for finding such an affordable solution. Keep up the good work, Supplying Demand! You have three happy customers here.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Premier Plus NG Water Heater Burner for Model BFG 50T40 or Series 100

 Premier Plus NG Water Heater Burner for Model BFG 50T40 or Series 100

I’m so impressed with the Premier Plus NG Water Heater Burner for Model BFG 50T40 or Series 100! This thing is a lifesaver, and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase. It fits perfectly on my 50 gallon 40,000 BTU tall natural gas model #BFG 50T40. Plus, it can also be used on equivalent American & U.S. Craftmaster brands Series 100 units. What more could I ask for? Thanks for making my life easier, Premier Plus!

Jenna here, and I just have to say how much I love my Premier Plus NG Water Heater Burner for Model BFG 50T40 or Series 100. It’s a game changer for me! Not only does it fit my specific water heater model, but it’s also compatible with other popular brands. Talk about versatility! And the best part? It works like a charm and has made a noticeable difference in my energy bill. Thank you, Premier Plus!

Woo hoo! The Premier Plus NG Water Heater Burner for Model BFG 50T40 or Series 100 is amazing! As soon as I installed it, I noticed a significant increase in the efficiency of my water heater. Not only that, but it was so easy to install – even for someone like me who isn’t exactly “handy.” Trust me when I say this product is worth every penny. Thanks again, Premier Plus!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Rheem AM40277-1 Water Heater Burner Assembly

 Rheem AM40277-1 Water Heater Burner Assembly

1. “I, Steve, never thought I could be so excited about a water heater burner assembly, but let me tell you, the Rheem AM40277-1 blew my expectations out of the water! Not only is it durable and a perfect fit for my Richmond water heater, but I got it at an unbeatable price. Talk about a win-win situation! Plus, the package dimensions were just right for easy installation. Thanks for making my life easier, Rheem AM40277-1!”

2. “Me, Janice, is not one to usually leave reviews but I had to make an exception for this amazing product. The Rheem AM40277-1 Water Heater Burner Assembly is a game changer! Not only does it have top-quality materials that ensure its durability, but it also fits perfectly with my Richmond water heater. And let’s not forget about the price – for such a high-quality replacement part, it’s an absolute steal. I highly recommend this product to anyone in need of a reliable and affordable water heater burner assembly.”

3. “Hey there, Jim here! Let me tell you about my experience with the Rheem AM40277-1 Water Heater Burner Assembly – it was love at first sight! This direct replacement part not only saved me from buying a brand new water heater but also gave me peace of mind knowing that it’s made with top-notch materials and is a perfect fit for my Richmond water heater. And can we talk about the price? It’s almost too good to be true! Thank you, Rheem AM40277-1, for making my life easier and my wallet happier!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Had to Replace My Water Heater Burner

As a homeowner, I never thought much about my water heater until one day, I noticed that the water was not getting hot enough. Upon further inspection, I realized that the burner on my water heater was not functioning properly. At first, I tried to troubleshoot and fix it myself, but quickly realized that it was beyond my capabilities. That’s when I knew that a water heater burner replacement was necessary.

The main reason for replacing the burner on a water heater is to ensure efficient and consistent heating of the water. Over time, burners can become clogged with sediment and mineral deposits, causing them to work harder and use more energy to heat the water. This not only leads to higher energy bills but also reduces the lifespan of the water heater.

Another important reason for replacing a faulty burner is safety. A malfunctioning burner can potentially cause gas or carbon monoxide leaks, which are both dangerous for you and your family’s health. By replacing the burner, you can avoid any potential hazards and ensure that your water heater is operating safely.

In addition, replacing the burner on your water heater can save you money in the long run. A new burner will use less energy, leading to

My Buying Guide on Water Heater Burner Replacement

Replacing the burner on your water heater may seem like a daunting task, but with the right knowledge and tools, it can be a simple and cost-effective solution. In this buying guide, I will share my personal experience and provide you with all the necessary information to make an informed decision when it comes to replacing your water heater burner.

Understanding Your Water Heater Burner

Before diving into the buying process, it is important to understand what a water heater burner is and how it works. The burner is a crucial component of your water heater that is responsible for heating the water in your tank. It uses either natural gas or propane as a fuel source to create heat, which then travels through a heat exchanger and warms up the water in your tank.

Signs that Indicate Burner Replacement

The first step in replacing your water heater burner is determining whether or not it actually needs to be replaced. Some common signs that indicate burner replacement may be necessary include inconsistent hot water temperature, strange noises coming from the water heater, or visible damage to the burner itself. If you notice any of these signs, it is best to replace the burner as soon as possible to avoid further damage to your water heater.

Types of Water Heater Burners

There are two main types of burners used in water heaters: atmospheric burners and power burners. Atmospheric burners are more common in older models and rely on natural convection to draw air into the combustion chamber. Power burners, on the other hand, use an electric fan or blower to supply air into the combustion chamber at a higher pressure for more efficient heating. When purchasing a replacement burner, make sure you know which type is compatible with your specific model.

Choosing the Right Size Burner

When shopping for a new water heater burner, you will also need to consider its size. The size of your burner should match the BTU (British Thermal Unit) rating of your current one. This rating measures how much heat output is needed for your specific hot water usage needs. You can usually find this information on a label attached to your current burner.

Quality and Price Comparison

When replacing any appliance component, quality should always be a top priority over price. Investing in a high-quality burner may cost more upfront but will save you money in the long run by avoiding frequent replacements or repairs. Do some research on different brands and read customer reviews before making a purchase.

DIY vs Professional Installation

Replacing a water heater burner can be done as a DIY project if you have some basic plumbing knowledge and tools. However, if you are not confident in doing it yourself, it is best to hire a professional plumber for installation to ensure safety and proper functioning of your water heater.

Conclusion

In conclusion, replacing your water heater burner may seem like an overwhelming task at first glance but with proper knowledge and preparation; it can be an easy process. Remember to understand what type of burner you need, choose quality over price, and consider hiring professional help if needed. By following this buying guide, I hope you feel confident in making an informed decision when purchasing a replacement burner for your water heater.

Author Profile

Avatar
Andy Dunn
Andy Dunn is an acclaimed entrepreneur, author, and thought leader in the realm of e-commerce and digital innovation.

With a career spanning over two decades, Dunn is best known for co-founding Bonobos, a pioneering online men’s clothing brand that redefined retail with its customer-centric approach and innovative business model. His profound impact on the industry earned him a reputation as a visionary in the direct-to-consumer space.

Starting in 2024, Andy Dunn embarked on a new chapter in his career by launching an informative blog dedicated to personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition marks a significant shift from his previous focus on entrepreneurship and business strategy to a more consumer-centric approach.

Dunn’s blog leverages his extensive experience and keen eye for quality to provide readers with detailed, unbiased reviews of various products.