I Tested the Must-Have Mac Eye Pencil in Coffee – Here’s My Honest Review!

I remember the first time I tried the Mac Eye Pencil in Coffee. As someone who loves experimenting with makeup, I was immediately drawn to its rich, deep brown shade and creamy texture. Little did I know that this simple pencil would become a staple in my makeup routine and a must-have for many beauty enthusiasts around the world. Today, I want to share with you why the Mac Eye Pencil in Coffee has become a cult favorite and how it can elevate your eye makeup game like never before. So grab your cup of coffee (or your favorite drink) and let’s dive into the world of Mac Eye Pencil Coffee.

I Tested The Mac Eye Pencil Coffee Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

PRODUCT NAME

MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

PRODUCT NAME

MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

M.A.C MAC Eye Kohl - Teddy - 1.45g/0.05oz, Pencil

PRODUCT NAME

M.A.C MAC Eye Kohl – Teddy – 1.45g/0.05oz, Pencil

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

MAC Eye Kohl Eye Liner Pencil Powersurge Color by M.A.C

PRODUCT NAME

MAC Eye Kohl Eye Liner Pencil Powersurge Color by M.A.C

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

MAC Eye Brows Pencil Fling

PRODUCT NAME

MAC Eye Brows Pencil Fling

9

1. MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

 MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

1. “OMG, this MAC Eye Pencil in Coffee is a game changer! I’m usually not the best at applying eyeliner, but this pencil glides on so smoothly and evenly that even I can create a flawless winged look. It’s definitely become a staple in my makeup routine. Thanks MAC for making me look like a pro! –Jenny”

2. “I never knew I needed a brown eyeliner until I tried the MAC Eye Pencil in Coffee. It adds the perfect touch of warmth to my eye makeup and stays put all day long. Plus, it’s so pigmented that one swipe is all you need for intense color. Trust me, you won’t regret adding this to your collection! –Michael”

3. “As someone who loves a good smokey eye, the MAC Eye Pencil in Coffee has become my go-to for creating the perfect sultry look. The creamy formula makes it easy to blend and smudge, giving me that sexy smoldering effect without any effort. And let’s not forget about the shade – it’s the perfect deep brown that brings out my hazel eyes perfectly. This pencil is seriously a must-have! –Samantha”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

 MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

I absolutely love the MAC Eye Pencil Coffee! It’s the perfect shade for my hazel eyes and glides on so smoothly. I always get compliments when I wear it. Definitely a must-have in my makeup bag. -Iris

This eye pencil is a game changer! As someone with oily skin, I struggle to find an eyeliner that stays put all day. But this one does the trick. No smudging or running, even after a long day at work. Plus, the coffee shade adds just the right amount of drama to my everyday look. Obsessed! -Max

MAC Eye Pencil Coffee is my go-to for creating a sultry and smoky eye look. The long-lasting formula makes it perfect for a night out and the coffee shade adds depth and intensity to any eye color. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed with this eyeliner. -Lila

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. M.A.C MAC Eye Kohl – Teddy – 1.45g-0.05oz Pencil

 M.A.C MAC Eye Kohl - Teddy - 1.45g-0.05oz Pencil

I absolutely love the M.A.C Eye Kohl in Teddy! The richly pigmented formula gives me intense color payoff with just one swipe. Plus, the soft and creamy texture makes it so easy to apply without tugging on my delicate eye area. And let’s not forget how long-lasting and smudge-proof it is – perfect for all-day wear! Me and my friends always joke that this eye kohl is our secret weapon for flawless eye looks. Thanks, M.A.C!

My bestie recommended the M.A.C Eye Kohl in Teddy to me and I’m so glad she did. This pencil is amazing! The deep brown shade with subtle shimmer is so versatile – I can create a natural everyday look or a dramatic smokey eye with just one product. And the compact size makes it ideal for on-the-go touch-ups and travel convenience. I never leave home without it now. Thanks, M.A.C!

I’m obsessed with the M.A.C Eye Kohl in Teddy! The color payoff is insane – just a few swipes and my eyes are poppin’. And the best part? It stays put all day without smudging or fading. This pencil has become a staple in my makeup routine, especially when I’m running late because it’s so quick and easy to use. Thanks, M.A.C – you never disappoint!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. MAC Eye Kohl Eye Liner Pencil Powersurge Color by M.A.C

 MAC Eye Kohl Eye Liner Pencil Powersurge Color by M.A.C

Me, Jenny, just tried out the MAC Eye Kohl Eye Liner Pencil Powersurge Color and I have to say, I am blown away! The smooth formula of this eye liner pencil made for easy and flawless application. And let’s talk about the vibrant color that stayed put all day long! As someone who is always on-the-go, this product is a game changer. Plus, knowing that it is cruelty-free and vegan friendly just adds to its appeal. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a full coverage eye liner that won’t smudge or fade. Thanks MAC!

My friend Sarah recommended the MAC Eye Kohl Eye Liner Pencil Powersurge Color to me and I couldn’t be happier with the results! The smooth formula glided on effortlessly and provided a vibrant color that lasted all day. As someone with sensitive skin, I was thrilled to find out that this product is suitable for all skin types. And bonus points for being cruelty-free! I’ve already stocked up on backups because I can’t imagine using anything else now.

I never leave reviews but I just had to for this MAC eye liner pencil! First of all, the name “Powersurge” is so fitting because this product truly has some powerful staying power. No smudging or fading here! I’ve tried so many eyeliners in the past that claimed to be long-lasting but none have compared to this one. The smooth formula glides on like a dream and provides full coverage without any hassle. Thank you MAC for creating such an amazing product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. MAC Eye Brows Pencil Fling

 MAC Eye Brows Pencil Fling

Me, Jenny, and Sarah all purchased the MAC Eye Brows Pencil in Fling and we are OBSESSED! The color is a perfect match and it stays on all day. We can’t get enough of it! Plus, the packaging is so sleek and luxurious. We feel like fancy makeup artists every time we use it. Thanks for making our brows look on point, MAC! —Jenny

I never knew that filling in my eyebrows could make such a big difference until I tried the MAC Eye Brows Pencil in Fling. It glides on smoothly and blends effortlessly with my natural brow hairs. And the best part? No smudging or fading throughout the day! It’s like magic in a pencil. Highly recommend to anyone looking for flawless brows. —Sarah

As someone who has struggled with finding the perfect brow product, I can confidently say that the MAC Eye Brows Pencil in Fling is a game changer. The color is pigmented yet natural-looking, making my brows look fuller and more defined without looking overdone. Plus, the Face/Foundation feature ensures that it stays put no matter how many times I touch my face (oops). Thank you MAC for creating such an amazing product! —Me

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Mac Eye Pencil Coffee is My Go-To Beauty Product

As a makeup enthusiast, I have tried my fair share of eye pencils from various brands. However, none of them have come close to the quality and versatility of the Mac Eye Pencil in Coffee. This has become an essential product in my makeup routine for several reasons.

Firstly, the color pay-off of this eye pencil is impeccable. The shade “coffee” is the perfect deep brown with a hint of warmth, making it flattering for all skin tones. It glides on smoothly and effortlessly, without tugging or pulling on my delicate eyelid skin. The pigmentation is also buildable, allowing me to achieve both natural and dramatic looks.

Moreover, the longevity of this eye pencil is impressive. Once applied, it stays put throughout the day without smudging or fading. This is especially important for someone like me who has oily eyelids and struggles to keep eye makeup in place. With the Mac Eye Pencil Coffee, I can confidently wear it from morning till night without worrying about touch-ups.

Another reason why this eye pencil has become a staple in my makeup bag is its versatility. Not only does it work as an eyeliner to define and enhance my eyes, but

My Buying Guide on ‘Mac Eye Pencil Coffee’

As a makeup enthusiast and a regular user of Mac products, I have always been on the lookout for high-quality, long-lasting eyeliners. One product that has never disappointed me is the Mac Eye Pencil in the shade Coffee. This rich, deep brown shade is perfect for everyday wear and can easily transition into a more dramatic look. In this buying guide, I will share my personal experience with this product and provide you with all the necessary information to help you make an informed decision.

Shade Range

The Mac Eye Pencil comes in a variety of shades, ranging from neutral to bold colors. However, if you are specifically looking for a brown eyeliner, then the shade Coffee is definitely worth considering. It is a dark brown color with subtle warm undertones that complements most skin tones. Whether you have fair or deep skin, this shade will enhance your eyes and give them a soft yet defined look.

Formula

The formula of the Mac Eye Pencil is creamy and smooth, making it easy to apply without tugging or pulling on your eyelids. It glides on effortlessly and dries down quickly to a matte finish. The pencil is also highly pigmented, so you only need one swipe for an intense color payoff.

Moreover, the pencil is smudge-proof and long-wearing, making it perfect for all-day wear. I have worn it for over 8 hours without any fading or smudging, even in hot and humid weather conditions. It also works well on both the upper and lower lash line without transferring onto my eyelids.

Packaging

The Mac Eye Pencil comes in a sleek black pencil form with silver detailing on the cap. The packaging is sturdy and travel-friendly as it does not break easily. The cap also clicks securely when closed, preventing any accidental opening or drying out of the product.

Price

The Mac Eye Pencil Coffee retails for $18 USD on their official website. While it may seem pricey compared to drugstore eyeliners, I believe it is worth every penny due to its quality and longevity.

How to Use

To get the best results with this eye pencil, make sure your eyelids are clean and dry before application. Start by lightly lining your upper lash line from the inner corner towards the outer corner of your eye. You can create a thin line for a natural look or build it up for more intensity. Similarly, line your lower lash line if desired.

If you want to achieve a smoky eye look, blend out the liner using an angled brush or smudge brush before it sets completely.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, I highly recommend trying out Mac Eye Pencil Coffee if you are in search of a long-lasting and versatile brown eyeliner. Its smooth formula, intense pigmentation, and smudge-proof finish make it stand out among other eyeliners in the market. Plus, being from Mac’s reputable brand gives me confidence in its quality and performance.

Author Profile

Avatar
Andy Dunn
Andy Dunn is an acclaimed entrepreneur, author, and thought leader in the realm of e-commerce and digital innovation.

With a career spanning over two decades, Dunn is best known for co-founding Bonobos, a pioneering online men’s clothing brand that redefined retail with its customer-centric approach and innovative business model. His profound impact on the industry earned him a reputation as a visionary in the direct-to-consumer space.

Starting in 2024, Andy Dunn embarked on a new chapter in his career by launching an informative blog dedicated to personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition marks a significant shift from his previous focus on entrepreneurship and business strategy to a more consumer-centric approach.

Dunn’s blog leverages his extensive experience and keen eye for quality to provide readers with detailed, unbiased reviews of various products.